Eloise's Easy Sugar Cookies Recipe - Food.com (2024)

156

1. 

   Will the dough be okay if I refrigerate the dough and then roll it out? Or should I wait until it warms up again?

   meeplnag

2. 

   What does "Cream butter and sugar" mean?

   Julie V.

3. 

   Do i melt the butter?

   V J.7575

   See Also

   2 Week Anti-Inflammatory Meal Plan - Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner Recipes - Word From The BirdThe Best Louisiana Crunch Cake Ever Recipe - Food.com4-ingredient Healthy Muddy Buddies Recipe (aka Healthy Puppy Chow)Bonefish Grill's Bang Bang Shrimp Recipe

4. 

   Can you use self rising flour instead?

   chelle.66

5. 

   Can this dough be rolled out, cut and then frozen for baking later?

   mishy_bc

see 14 more questions

Reviews

1. 

   I test made this recipe to see if I could double the batch, it worked great! Fabulous and super easy to work with, not needing to chill first is a real bonus! I love the cookie without the icing, my husband loves it with. Great for decorating! Highly recommend this recipe for the home baker.

   • 

   mishy_bc

2. 

   These sugar cookies are simple and delicious. Making the dough is really quick, too, though the rolling and cutting does take a bit of time. I made a half batch of the recipe on two separate occasions this week, the second time dividing the dough into 3 batches: one plain, one with mixed dried fruit (raisins, craisins and blueberries), and one with mini chocolate chips. They all came out beautifully; thin and crisp! I highly recommend this recipe and will definitely use it again and again.

   day-hee

3. 

   I used real butter and hand mixed everything. 1/4 of dry ingredients at a time. I refrigeratedon't the dough for an hour and didn't need any flour to roll it out. Not sticky at all. I baked them for 8 minutes. These are soft moist and so so tasty. I was worried after reading some reviews about them being bland or dry. I'm not sure where they went wrong or I went right but these are delicious cookies. I've never baked sugar cookies before. I'm just broke and happened to have the ingredients and wanted to make cookies for my kids. I highly recommend these. I'll definitely save this recipie. This picture is half of the recipie. I have the rest in the fridge for later.

   • 

   Kama S.

   See Also

   Keto Dutch Baby Pancake Recipe

4. 

   I have tried 6 different recipes in the past week, trying to get the perfect taste and consistency for my Royal Icing decorated cookies. I FINALLY found it! I doubled the recipe, which worked perfectly. The only thing I changed was the baking powder. I halved the amount it called for. Some people have said they are "salty", I don't understand that. Mine aren't salty at all! They held their shape perfectly and after decorating with Royal Icing, they tasted perfect. This is not meant to be a "sweet cookie". If you are wanting a sweet cookie, you should probably use a sugar cookie recipe. I will use this recipe from now on. I make and decorate a lot of cookies for many different occasions and this will now be my #1 recipe. Also, I NEVER use flour to roll out my cookies. I always roll them out on parchment paper sprinkled with powdered sugar.

   • 

   Melissa C.

5. 

   These are the best sugar cookies EVER! I've never made cookies in my life and I tried this recipe ( didn't change anything on it) and they turned out AWESOME, thanks so much!

   • 

   karencita7

see 147 more reviews

Tweaks

1. 

   Pretty good. I do prefer softer, sweeter cookies and these bake harder and are not that sweet. Only problem was that the dough turned crumbly after mixing, even though I followed directions and softened the butter before use. To solve, I added a few drops of water at a time to the crumbly dough, until it was smooth and pliable. A tip I read: use confectioner sugar instead of flour to roll out dough. That really helped add more sweetness! I'm giving a 4 due to not needing to refrigerate prior to use, recipe ease, and fact that dough held the cookie cutter shapes. Would make again as my 9, 4, and yr old loved them :)

   Cant Boil Water

2. 

   Doubled the batch...worked great!

   mishy_bc

3. 

   Adding 1/4 cup of shredded fresh ginger, a teaspoon of cinnamon, 1/2 teaspoon of nutmeg adds a nice flavor

   cassanna15

4. 

   I added a bit more vanilla than called for

   lexisandiford

5. 

   Double batch for Christmas. Was delicious! I recommend it. One thing is that that it needs a little more wet ingredients because it kind of fell apart at first. So I added some water. Turned out great! Altogether very good recipe they were very delicious!!

   Jaden R.

see 17 more tweaks

Advertisem*nt

Advertisem*nt

Advertisem*nt